Should government meetings open with a prayer?

Should government meetings open with a prayer?

In a lot of countries, government meetings still open with a prayer. A chaplain prays before the US Senate gets to work. Local councils from North Carolina to Devon have done the same. Supporters see a harmless tradition that adds a moment of reflection. Critics see the government picking a religion in a room where everyone is supposed to be equal.

This is one of those questions where the law is genuinely interesting, the courts have not all agreed, and reasonable people land in different places. So here is a straight explainer: what the law actually says in a few countries, and the strongest arguments on each side.

The United States: tradition wins, with limits

The US Constitution’s First Amendment says Congress shall make no law “respecting an establishment of religion.” You might expect that to rule out official prayers. The Supreme Court has said otherwise, at least for legislatures.

Congress has done it from the start. The House and Senate have had chaplains since 1789, and the House chaplain still opens each day’s session with a prayer (Office of the House Chaplain; Wikipedia: Chaplain of the US Senate).

Marsh v. Chambers (1983). Nebraska’s legislature paid a chaplain to open its sessions with prayer. The Supreme Court upheld it, leaning heavily on history: the same First Congress that drafted the First Amendment also hired chaplains, so the founders clearly did not see the two as contradictory (Marsh v. Chambers, 463 U.S. 783).

Town of Greece v. Galloway (2014). This case moved the question down to local government. The town board of Greece, New York opened its meetings with prayers, nearly all of them Christian. Two residents, one Jewish and one atheist, sued. In a 5 to 4 decision, the Court upheld the practice. It said prayers do not have to be non-sectarian, and the town does not have to go looking for religious diversity beyond its borders. But it set limits: a prayer practice could cross the line if, over time, prayers denigrate non-believers or minority faiths, threaten damnation, or try to convert people, or if officials pressure citizens to take part (Town of Greece v. Galloway, 572 U.S. 565; Oyez summary).

Who prays matters. After Greece, two federal appeals courts looked at county commissioners who led the prayers themselves, rather than inviting guest clergy. In North Carolina, the Fourth Circuit struck down Rowan County’s practice, pointing to commissioners delivering almost exclusively Christian prayers and inviting the audience to join in (Lund v. Rowan County, 4th Cir. 2017). In Michigan, the Sixth Circuit upheld a similar practice in Jackson County (Bormuth v. County of Jackson, 6th Cir. 2017). Same basic question, opposite answers, and the Supreme Court declined to resolve it.

Schools are different. Official prayer in public schools has been unconstitutional since Engel v. Vitale (1962), largely because children are a captive audience. In 2022, Kennedy v. Bremerton School District told courts to interpret the Establishment Clause by “reference to historical practices and understandings,” which most observers read as making long-standing traditions like legislative prayer even more secure (Oyez summary).

England: banned, then legalised

In 2012, the National Secular Society and a former councillor challenged Bideford Town Council in Devon, which opened its meetings with prayers. The High Court ruled that the Local Government Act 1972 did not give councils the power to hold prayers as part of the formal business of a meeting. Notably, it rejected the argument that the prayers breached anyone’s human rights. It was a ruling about council powers, not religious freedom (National Secular Society v Bideford Town Council [2012] EWHC 175 (Admin)).

Parliament responded. The Local Government (Religious etc. Observances) Act 2015 explicitly allows local authorities in England to include prayers or other religious observances in their meetings (legislation.gov.uk).

Canada: neutrality wins

Canada went the other way. The mayor of Saguenay, Quebec opened council meetings with a Catholic prayer, complete with the sign of the cross. A resident who is an atheist complained. In 2015, the Supreme Court of Canada ruled unanimously that the prayer breached the state’s duty of religious neutrality and interfered with his freedom of conscience and religion, and it ordered the prayer stopped (Mouvement laïque québécois v. Saguenay (City), 2015 SCC 16).

The case for opening with a prayer

  • History and tradition. The practice is older than many of the institutions using it. Supporters argue that something the founders did alongside writing the rules can hardly violate those rules.
  • It is ceremonial. Like a national anthem, a short prayer can mark the start of serious business and remind officials of something bigger than themselves.
  • Nobody is forced to pray. Attendees can sit quietly, step out or arrive after. US courts have stressed that the prayer is mainly for the lawmakers, not the public.
  • It reflects the community. If most people in a town are religious, supporters say, banning prayer can feel like the state taking sides against them.

The case against

  • Government should not pick a faith. When the prayers are overwhelmingly from one religion, critics argue, the state is effectively endorsing it.
  • Local meetings are not Congress. At a town council, ordinary residents show up to ask for a permit or raise a complaint, often in a small room facing the people who will decide. Declining to stand or bow in that setting can feel risky.
  • It excludes people. Atheists, religious minorities and believers who prefer to keep faith private can be made to feel like outsiders in their own civic space.
  • There are alternatives. A moment of silence, or reflection open to everyone, achieves the solemnity without the theology.

So, where does that leave us?

The short version: in the US, opening prayers are generally legal as long as they do not become coercive or turn into sermons against other people; in England they are now expressly permitted; in Canada, municipal prayer is out. The disagreement comes down to how you weigh tradition against neutrality, and whether you picture the prayer from the front of the room or from the public seats.

We are genuinely curious where you land. Should government meetings open with a prayer, a moment of silence, or nothing at all? Tell us on the Facebook page, and keep it civil.

Newsletter

The weekly heresy

Best of the page + new articles, every Sunday. No sermons.

Free, one email a week, unsubscribe in one click. We use your email only for this newsletter and never share it. Privacy policy.


Got thoughts? Join the discussion on The Atheist Jew on Facebook.