Walk into a Texas public school classroom this year and you may see a poster, at least 16 inches by 20, hanging in a conspicuous place. It does not start with a school rule or a civic motto. It starts with a theological claim: “I AM the LORD thy God.”
The Supreme Court looked at a poster almost exactly like that in 1980 and said no. Forty-six years later, Texas, Louisiana and Arkansas have tried again. One of those laws is in force. The Court has not yet said whether it will take another look.
What the Court said in 1980
In Stone v. Graham, 449 U.S. 39 (1980), the Court struck down a Kentucky statute that required a copy of the Ten Commandments in every public school classroom. The poster had to be 16 by 20 inches, could be paid for with private donations, and even carried a small-print note about the Commandments as “the fundamental legal code of Western Civilization.” None of that saved it.
The Court’s point was blunt. The Ten Commandments are a sacred text in the Jewish and Christian faiths, and “no legislative recitation of a supposed secular purpose can blind us to that fact.” The later lines about killing, stealing and false witness may sound like ordinary ethics. The opening ones do not: exclusive worship of one God, no graven images, no taking the Lord’s name in vain, and a holy Sabbath. Posting the text on a classroom wall, the Court said, served no educational function. If it worked at all, it would be to get schoolchildren “to read, meditate upon, perhaps to venerate and obey” the Commandments. That may be a fine goal for a home or a synagogue. It is not a job for the state. The Bible can still be taught as history or comparative religion. A poster on the chemistry-lab wall is not that.
Texas tries it anyway
Senate Bill 10 requires a durable poster or framed copy of the Ten Commandments, in wording the statute sets out word for word, in a conspicuous place in each public elementary and secondary classroom. The poster must be at least 16 by 20 inches and readable from anywhere in the room. Schools must accept a privately donated copy that meets those rules, and may buy one with district funds. The law applies from the 2025–26 school year and took effect on September 1, 2025. The Senate passed it 20 to 11; the House, 82 to 46.
Families of more than one faith sued, including rabbis, a cantor and a Christian minister. A federal district court blocked the law. On April 21, 2026, the full U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit reversed, by a 9 to 8 vote, and dismissed the challenge. The majority held that the displays do not establish a religion or substantially burden religious exercise, and that Stone no longer controls after the Supreme Court moved away from older Establishment Clause tests (Nathan v. Alamo Heights Independent School District, 5th Cir. 2026). The dissenters said Stone is still binding until the Supreme Court itself overrules it.
The families asked the Supreme Court to take the case. The petition in Nathan v. Alamo Heights Independent School District, No. 26-257, was filed in August 2026. Texas filed a brief opposing review on November 10. The Court has not said whether it will hear the case.
On November 9, 2026, Sen. José Menéndez filed Senate Bill 115, which would repeal the classroom-poster rule. Filing a bill is not the same as repealing a law. Official records still list it as filed, not yet in committee (Texas Legislature Online). The Legislature convenes on January 12, 2027. Until it acts, or the Supreme Court does, the poster rule remains the law in Texas.
Louisiana and Arkansas
Louisiana moved first. House Bill 71, signed on June 19, 2024, as Act 676, requires a Ten Commandments display in public school classrooms, with a required context statement, while leaving much of the design to local school boards. A district court blocked it. On February 20, 2026, the Fifth Circuit, sitting en banc, vacated that injunction. It did not bless the law as constitutional. It held that the challenge was not ripe, because too much about how the displays would look and be used was still unknown (Roake v. Brumley, 5th Cir. 2026). Louisiana has asked the Supreme Court to take up the case if it takes the Texas one (Brumley v. Roake, No. 25-1360). A Louisiana teacher has a separate petition pending (Dier v. Landry, No. 26-256).
Arkansas passed Act 573 of 2025, which requires a conspicuous 16-by-20-inch “historical representation” of the Ten Commandments, in prescribed wording, in public school classrooms and libraries when donated or privately funded copies are available. In March 2026, U.S. District Judge Timothy Brooks permanently blocked the law in the six districts named in the suit, writing that nothing could justify hanging the Commandments in “a calculus, chemistry, French, or woodworking class” (Arkansas Advocate). The Eighth Circuit heard the state’s appeal on September 22, 2026, and has not yet issued a decision (Arkansas Advocate).
Which Ten Commandments, exactly?
Here is the part the “historical document” talking point keeps tripping over. Jews, Catholics and Protestants do not even agree on how to number the Commandments, or on the exact wording. Texas chose a Protestant, King James-style text: “Thou shalt not kill,” a ban on “graven images,” and a Sabbath line that, depending on who you ask, is about Saturday or Sunday. That is not a neutral civics poster. It is the state picking a side in a centuries-old religious argument and hanging the winning draft on the wall.
About 1.9 billion people worldwide have no religion, and about three in ten U.S. adults are unaffiliated. The figures, and their sources, are on our Atheist Counter. A poster that begins “I AM the LORD thy God” is not speaking for everyone in the room. If classrooms are going to hang commandments at all, the one we can get behind is Thou Shalt Fact-Check.
So where does that leave the classroom?
As of November 21, 2026, Texas law requires the posters, and a closely divided appeals court has allowed that to stand. Louisiana’s law is no longer blocked by the first injunction, but its constitutionality was not decided. Arkansas’s law is blocked in the districts that were sued, with an appeal pending. The Supreme Court has three related petitions and has not yet agreed to hear any of them. Stone v. Graham has not been overruled.
A monument on capitol grounds is not the same thing as a required poster in a room of children who cannot leave. The Court drew that kind of line in 1980, and again when it later allowed a capitol-grounds display in Texas. The new laws test whether that line still holds.
Where do you land? Should a public school classroom display the Ten Commandments, teach them as history, or leave them to homes and congregations? Tell us on the Facebook page, and keep it civil.



